Updated daily · 18 Nov 2026
Player reception
Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure
As of 18 November 2026, 91% of 355 player reviews of Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure recommend it. The sequel to the RuneScape-inspired idle game came out in early access on 17 November. Players who loved the first Melvor Idle call it a prettier, deeper step up, and some find it too close to the original.
In short
Players praise a cleaner, better-looking interface, new skills and linked systems that promise months of goals, and changes that cut the busywork of the first game, such as stop conditions for idle play and loadouts for each skill. Fans of Melvor Idle mostly see it as an improvement in nearly every area. The complaints are that much of it mirrors the first game, menus that still need sorting and search, a slow, grindy start where rare drops have no bad-luck protection, and features still marked as coming soon. Fans of the first game who are happy to grow with early access get the most from it, and players wanting a finished game should wait.

What players say
What players say about Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure.
Players praise the new interface, the depth and the quality-of-life changes. Too much of the first game, rough menus, a grindy start and unfinished features are the main complaints.268
Read in full
We read every one of these reviews on 18 November 2026 and judged each by what it says.
- It looks and feels a step up.
- The interface is cleaner and more polished, with smoother animations, new music and art that looks better than the first game’s.268
- Fans call it better in nearly every way.
- Players who know Melvor Idle say the sequel improves on most of it, with more depth and more to explore.268
- There are months of goals ahead.
- New skills that feed into each other and a long list of targets have players expecting to keep going for months.268
- It cuts the first game’s busywork.
- Stop conditions for idle play, a loadout for each skill and banked combat loot remove chores the first game had.268
- Some find it too close to the original.
- Much of the content mirrors the first game, and some players see fewer new systems than they hoped for.268
- The start is slow and grindy.
- Early progress drags, and rare drops come without the bad-luck protection the first game had, so some grinds stretch into weeks.268
- It still feels early.
- Placeholder art, features marked as coming soon, and menus without sorting or search leave some players waiting for updates.268
Themes raised
| Theme | Most helpful, of 56 | Latest, of 31 |
|---|---|---|
| Compared with the first game | 30 | 14 |
| Interface, art and sound | 18 | 13 |
| Content and depth | 15 | 5 |
| Early access and unfinished features | 9 | 3 |
| Progression and grind | 8 | 2 |
| Combat and gear | 7 | 1 |
| Mods | 7 | 3 |
| The RuneScape link | 7 | 3 |
| Price and monetisation | 6 | 1 |
| Farming and automation | 4 | 0 |
Questions
Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure, in short.
Is Melvor Idle 2 worth it?
Most players say yes. As of 18 November 2026, 91% of 355 reviews recommend it. Fans of the first game who want a deep idle game recommend buying now, and others suggest waiting for more early-access updates.268
Is Melvor Idle 2 better than Melvor Idle?
Most players who played both say yes, for the interface, the depth and the reduced busywork. Some find too much of it mirrors the first game.268
How much is Melvor Idle 2, and is it in early access?
What’s new in Melvor Idle 2’s early access?
Three new skills, Astrology, Herblore and Agility, plus more than 1,100 new items, 121 new enemies and Act 2 of the quests, which takes players to around level 70. A sidebar in the style of the first game is on by default.269
Does Melvor Idle 2 demo progress carry over?
One player reports that their demo progress didn’t carry over to early access, and the studio’s launch post doesn’t mention bringing saves across.268
Does Melvor Idle 2 have microtransactions?
Players who mention it say no, and no review reports paying for an advantage.268
Cite or embed
Quote this page or embed its badge.
You can quote our findings and figures with a link back to this page. The badge’s figure updates every day. How to use our research.
Link
https://creativecult.digital/games/melvor-idle-2Citation
Creative Cult (2026). How players received Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure. Updated 18 November 2026. https://creativecult.digital/games/melvor-idle-2Figure
As of 18 November 2026, 91% of 355 player reviews of Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure recommend it. Source: Creative Cult, https://creativecult.digital/games/melvor-idle-2Badge

<a href="https://creativecult.digital/games/melvor-idle-2"><img src="https://creativecult.digital/games/melvor-idle-2/badge.png" width="320" height="100" alt="How players received Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure, by Creative Cult"></a>Iframe
<iframe src="https://creativecult.digital/games/melvor-idle-2/embed" width="320" height="100" title="How players received Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure, by Creative Cult" style="border:0" loading="lazy"></iframe>